Terminating the HUD Bots
First published in InsidePoker magazine, November 2009.
Introduction
The advent of the tracking database, and the Heads Up Display (HUD), has had a massive effect on online poker over the last few years. If you want to learn about what a HUD is and how to use one, check out Shaun Dean's articles at insidepokermag.co.uk. If you haven't heard the term 'HUD Bot' before, it's a derogatory term for an unimaginative player who ignores Shaun's advice, and relies too heavily on their HUD for information.
The truth is, there are a lot of players out there who fit this bill and misuse their HUD, particularly in low and mid-stakes games (up to about $2/$4 NL). Typically, a HUD Bot will be playing a very tight game on more tables than they can really handle, and will therefore have to make quick decisions based on a few simple stats. HUDs have some serious inherent weaknesses, and skilled players can exploit both those weaknesses and the straightforwardness of their opponents' play to maximise profit.
The Weaknesses of HUD Stats
When you first started to take poker seriously, you probably learned about the importance of position and the size of the pot to your success. However, a HUD never learned these lessons, and completely ignores them when it comes to displaying information.
Take a simple and important stat, such as '3-Bet %' (the percentage of the time that a player reraises a raise before the flop). This stat doesn't tell you whether the player who three-bet was in second position and reraised an under-the-gun raise, or whether they were on the button and three-bet after the cutoff opened - and of course there is a huge difference between the two. In fact, if I three-bet every time a player in a steal position raised before the flop, I would end up with a very high 3-Bet %.
Another important stat is 'C-Bet %' (the percentage of the time that a player bets the flop after raising preflop). However this statistic doesn't tell you anything about how big the pots were when that player made his continuation bets. In a $2/$4 game, there's a big difference between c-betting $200 into a $200 pot, and c-betting $10 into a $30 pot.
Over tens of thousands of hands, these differences become less and less important. However, at the big sites it's unlikely that your opponents will have that many hands on you. Typically, they might make their decisions based on less than a hundred hands, and that small sample size makes the stats they collect even less accurate, even in the unlikely event that those stats are correctly interpreted.
It should be clear then, that stats taken in isolation, particularly if those stats are based on a small number of hands, can be extremely misleading. But it's what so many players are doing these days, so let's talk through a few ways to make those stats even more misleading for your opponents!
Online Image Plays
Creating a false impression of how you play in the heads of your opponents is nothing new. People like Mike Caro have written at great length about how to get your opponents to think that you're a loose, gambling player even though your chips might be nailed to the felt! Sometimes, it can take just one memorable crazy play to forever change your table image.
In a live game, you might worry about your opponents not remembering your 'image plays' because they're not paying attention or they're not sophisticated enough to understand them. Usually, such a concern is even more true on the internet, and I usually advocate straightforward play for this reason. But if you know you're up against a HUD bot, you can pretty much guarantee that your image play will be right there, on their screen, next to your name, until they leave.
Because HUD bots tend to be extremely tight, it's to your advantage to create a loose image which will encourage them to pay you off when you hit a big hand. But how do you create a loose image in the minds of your HUD bot opponents, when they're probably playing 24 tables and not watching the individual hands? You do it by manipulating the stats that your opponents see to your favour.
Creating Misleading HUD Stats
Let's look at three scenarios from the same $2/$4 NL 9-Max ring game online. In all three hands, you are on the button.
Scenario A: It's folded to the cutoff who raises to $12. You reraise to $40.
Scenario B: It's folded to the cutoff who raises to $8. You reraise to $12.
Scenario C: The under the gun player raises to $25. You reraise to $100.
In all three scenarios, the effect on HUD stats is identical. However, the scenarios are completely different - in Scenario B, your range of hands is very wide, while in Scenario C you will almost certainly have pocket aces or kings. Since we want to create a loose image for ourselves which will help us to get paid off in situations like Scenario C, we can inflate our '3-Bet' and 'Aggression Factor' numbers by being more aggressive in situations like A and B.
For example, we could three-bet every single time the initial raise came from a steal position, and we will have position after the flop. For example, we can three-bet every time we are on the button and the cutoff raises. Or we can three-bet from the big blind every time the small blind raises. Such an adjustment would be a minor mistake at worst, but might help us to get paid off in a really big pot in the future.
Another stat which is easy to manipulate is the 'C-Bet %'. Ideally, you want to create a c-bet percentage which is high, but not 100%. If your c-bet percentage is 100%, then many opponents will correctly call your flop bet in order to take the pot away from you on the turn, which stops you from winning the pot when you flop nothing. The correct percentage to aim for is probably around 75%, which strikes a nice balance between letting your opponents fold when you have nothing, and give you action when you have something.
Again, let's look at three scenarios from a $2/$4 game:
Scenario A: The pot is $30, and you bet $15.
Scenario B: The pot is $30, and you bet $4.
Scenario C: The pot is $200 (there was heavy action preflop), and you bet $200.
You can create a high c-bet percentage at relatively low risk by betting more often in situations like Scenario A and B, when the time the pot is relatively small - lets say just your initial raise and a single opponent's call. However, in bigger pots like Scenario C you will want to be pretty sure of your hand before making that huge continuation bet, so you'll bet less often. HUD bot opponents won't know the difference between the situations - they will just see the combined stat which doesn't accurately represent your actual behaviour.
If you're feeling bold, there are some even more outrageous ways to exploit HUD bot opponents. For example, you could make a very small continuation bet (say a third of the pot) when you've missed the flop, but make a very large bet (perhaps the size of the pot or more) when you've hit it. Since the HUD doesn't know the difference, neither will your opponent, and you'll be maximising your value when you have the goods while risking little when you don't. Likewise, you could make very large 3-bets when you have the goods, but very small ones when you're picking off a loose opener. Of course, if you go that far, you'll need to be very sure that you're up against a HUD bot, because a regular opponent will quickly turn such a strategy against you!
Being Aware
When you deceive your opponents by creating a false image, you need to be well aware of that image and how it will affect how your opponents play against you. In this case, you should be very aware of the stats you are creating at each table you're playing, which might mean using a HUD yourself, to follow your own image as well as your opponents.
In particular, be very wary of your image over your first few hands at the table. It might be that you currently have a 100% c-bet percentage for example, which means you should probably slow down on the c-bets in upcoming hands as your opponents will be more likely than usual to bluff you.
Conclusion
Some players complain about HUD bots - they see HUDs as an unfair advantage, or are frustrated because they can't beat players who use them. But like any group of players that focuses too much on one particular aspect of the game, they can be exploited for profit. All it takes is a little imagination.