Decoding the Metagame
First published in PokerPlayer magazine, issue 57, February 2010.
Background
People love to give fancy-sounding names to simple concepts. You don't fire people, you downsize. You don't abort a child, you give it a near-life experience. Doyle Brunson isn't fat, he's a person of mass.
Well, as you have probably noticed, poker is no different. Metagame is a term that gets a lot of attention, but it's a really simple concept. In a poker sense, the metagame is everything you can't quantify, everything you can't assign a percentage to. It means going beyond the simple mechanics of the game - the bets, chips, and cards. The metagame means thinking about things like physical tells, your opponent's emotional state, your history with a particular opponent, and how you are perceived at the table.
An example of a situation where you might think about the metagame is when you're in late position in a No Limit Hold'em tournament, and it's folded to you. In the absence of all other information, the usual play is to raise, hoping that everybody will fold and you'll win the blinds. However, the metagame may influence your decision in a number of ways.
Maybe you raised five times in a row and showed a weak hand each time, but now you have a monster. You may want to make the same play of raising and hope your opponents perceive you as weak, and get involved when they shouldn't.
Alternatively, maybe you have a fairly good but not great hand this time (like A-5 offsuit, or K-J). You might choose to fold this hand, simply because you don't want to steal too many pots in a single orbit and encourage your opponents to play back at you. You're making a slightly less profitable play in the short-term, hoping to reap benefits in the long term.
The Importance of the Metagame
The metagame is an important part of a well-balanced approach to poker. After all, if you focus only on the cards that are on the table and the maths, then you're no better than a robot.
The metagame should rarely be used as an excuse for a play that doesn't make any sense in ordinary strategic terms. For example, you wouldn't fold pocket aces before the flop because of metagame considerations! Instead, it should help you to choose between two or more close decisions.
For example, let's say you have top pair, top kicker on the river, and your opponent has bet into you. This is rarely a raising situation, so you need to know whether this bet is a value bet and you should fold, or whether it's a bluff and you should call. Let's put aside the usual strategy concerns for a second, and focus on the metagame.
First of all, is your opponent giving off any physical tells? An opponent who is acting weak or disinterested, or who looks particularly alert, is often strong. An opponent who has frozen still, or an opponent who is staring intently at you, is often weak.
Next, is your opponent playing their best game? If your opponent is drunk, tired, or emotional (perhaps due to tilt, or due to problems outside the game), the chances are they are playing differently to usual. A player on tilt might see the river with hands they would normally fold, or might be desperately trying to win their money back by bluffing heavily.
What is your image at the table? If you've been showing down weak hands and making loose calls, you probably have a wild image. Your opponent might be betting with a marginal holding, expecting you to pay him off lightly. If you have such an image it's also less likely that your opponent is trying to bluff you. Conversely, if you have a very tight image, your opponent will probably try to bluff you more often.
Lastly, think about your history with your opponent, both throughout this session and previous ones. Are there any memorable hands where your opponent bet into you on the river? If so, what did they show? All of these factors may help to tip your decision one way or the other.
The metagame isn't just for people playing at an EPT final table, or playing in the Big Game in Vegas. It can be important in small-stakes games too, as long as the players are taking the game seriously. If the players aren't taking the game seriously, they will often play in an unpredictable fashion and won't pay much attention.
The metagame requires a long-term outlook in order to be useful. For example, if you make a play in order to build a specific image in your opponents' minds, you should be sure that you're going to be playing more hands with those players. Otherwise, you made a sub-optimal play for no future benefit.
Similarly, there is no point in carefully observing your opponents' tendencies if you will never play another hand with them. The metagame becomes a more important consideration when you're playing against the same players, day after day.
For those reasons, metagame considerations are much more valuable if you play in the same poker club each week, or in an online game where the player pool is small. There's not much point in constantly thinking about the metagame if you play, for example, $0.25/$0.50 NL Hold'em at a big site, where there are hundreds of tables running simultaneously and millions of players, although you should make an effort to identify other regulars and their tendencies where you can.
Downsides to the Metagame
If you read the online poker forums, you'll most usually see the term metagame associated with tricky plays. For example, 'I raised the river with 6-3 and showed it for the metagame. The guy went nuts'. However, you have to be careful not to fall into the mindset of 'tricky plays are glamorous and fun', justifying those plays as metagame considerations. Every play you make should have sound reasoning, and there should be another reason to make that play, besides the metagame.
Another potential pitfall is outthinking yourself, or making up metagame considerations that don't exist. A very common example of this is an otherwise-good player giving a weak opponent too much credit for sophisticated thinking. The weak opponent bets all-in, and the player dwells for a long time, thinking about whether the all-in bet is actually a bluff, because the big bet could actually mean weakness. Or maybe it's a subtle double-bluff, feigning weakness with a big bet to encourage a call? In reality, this player is just outthinking themselves and wasting their time. Weak players usually fold awful hands, check and call medium hands, and bet or raise good hands. The decision is a simple strategic one, and the metagame doesn't really come into it.
Always be cautious. The metagame is a tiny weight tips the scales between close decisions - it's not a ten-tonne anvil that makes the decision for you.
Farha vs Antonius
This hand comes from High Stakes Poker Season 4. The blinds are $300/$600 with a $1,200 forced straddle, and the stacks are very deep. Sammy Farha opens from the hijack with Kd-Qd to $4,200. Patrick Antonius, on the button, reraises to $16,000 with Jh-9h, and Sammy calls quickly.
The flop comes 6d 3c 9d, giving Farha a flush draw with two overcards, and Antonius top pair. The pot is $54,200 at this point, and Farha checks to Antonius, who bets $20,000. Farha quickly raises to $100,000. Antonius dwells a little, then moves all-in for $482,300. Farha insta-calls, making a pot of $998,800.
What are these two guys thinking? Well, it's clear that the metagame is involved here. Both players have a reputation for being loose and aggressive, and that had to be playing on their minds throughout the hand.
Farha's open raise is standard. Antonius is on the button and, against a loose opening raiser who could be stealing, is going to reraise with a wide range of hands - both to isolate on a single player when in position, and give himself a chance to win the pot immediately if Farha opened with trash. J-9s fits that bill nicely!
Antonius probably knows from prior experience that if Sammy has missed the flop altogether, he will fold to a small bet, so that's what he makes. Farha, on the other hand, knows that Antonius will make this bet with anything, so he raises as a semi-bluff. Antonius, knowing that Farha is loose, tricky, and apt to bluff, decides his hand is probably good, so raises all-in (Farha's quick check-raise may also have been a physical tell). Lastly, Farha, knowing that Antonius knows all of this, decides his flush draw and overcards are worth a gamble!
There is also one overriding metagame consideration - the game is being played on TV and it's great for both players if they continue to be perceived as loose and crazy by their opponents.
As the situation is so close, the players agree to run it four times. Antonius wins three quarters of the pot.