Polarised Hand Ranges

First published in PokerPlayer magazine, issue 60, May 2010.

Introduction

It’s amazing how much poker has moved on in the last few years. Not long ago, it was common to hear a discussion at the table that started like this:

‘Why didn’t you raise the river with your Jacks full?’

‘I put him on pocket kings.’

These days, you can still hear such thinking vocalised at tables full of beginners. But players with any sort of sophistication to their game have moved on, and are now talking about hand ranges instead.

Thinking through poker situations by assigning specific hands to your opponents is an elementary mistake, because it’s impossible to be 100% certain about even the most straightforward player’s holding. Mike Caro explained this well, via his ‘law of loose wiring’:

‘If choices are not clearly connected to their benefits, people usually interact in ways that make outcomes unpredictable. If choices are clearly connected to their benefits, people sometimes act in ways that make outcomes unpredictable.’

To put it simply, if you present the exact same situation to a typical poker player multiple times, it’s likely that each time they will make a slightly different decision. For example, give the same player pocket aces under the gun twice in a row. The first hand, they might raise to 3 times the big blind. The next hand, they might simply call. Both choices have merit, and there is an element of randomness as to which decision the player will actually make.

Because players are so unpredictable, it makes no sense to assign specific hands to opponents. Instead, you talk about a player’s range of possible hands. For example, suppose a player moves all-in on the river, and there are three hearts on board. You might decide that his range of hands includes any two hearts, any pair which made a set, any two cards which make a straight, and a few complete bluffs.

You can then use any poker calculator which supports hand ranges, such as PokerStove, to determine your chances of being ahead, and make an educated decision about whether to call or not.

What is a Polarised Range?

A polarised range means that, in a particular situation, a player’s range of hands is overly skewed towards having either a very strong hand or a bluff, with little in between. In the three hearts example, we saw that the all-in players range included not only made flushes, but also straights, sets, and bluffs.

However, let’s change the example a little. Now, everyone at the table limps in before the flop, and checks it to the river. The final board is Kh Qh 8h 6h 2c, meaning that anyone with a heart has a flush. The under-the-gun player moves all-in. What do you think his range of hands is?

This is a basic, and somewhat extreme, example of a polarised range. It’s quite unlikely that any player would be moving all-in for value with a hand such as 8-8 (bottom set on the flop), given the action before the river and the low likelihood of being called by a worse hand. That means the only two types of hands which make sense to bet are complete bluffs (because there is no way to win the pot without betting) and strong flushes (for value).

You say that the under-the-gun player has a polarised range because he either has a monster or a bluff. A polarised range can actually make your decision easier, by reducing the possibilities you have to consider. Backtracking throughout the hand may enable you to eliminate one end of the range or the other, or you may be able to do so by reading your opponent’s body language. Clearly, if there are two diametrically-opposed possibilities and you eliminate one of them, your decision becomes a lot easier!

A polarised range doesn’t always come about on the river – in fact, at any time your opponent can have a range of hands, it’s possible for them to have a polarised range. Because you use all the information available to you to narrow down your opponent’s range – the texture of the board, position, bet sizing, opponent tendencies and more – you can assign a polarised range to a player any time they’ve taken an action and you have information about the situation.

The most obvious examples of polarised ranges occur on heavily textured boards – for example, four-flush and four-straight boards, or boards with four of a kind. However, polarised situations can arise before the flop too, and it’s not always a ‘nuts or nothing’ situation. For example, you’re in the early stages of a mid-stakes live tournament with deep stacks, and are in the small blind with pocket jacks. The blinds are 50/100. It’s folded to the button, who raises to 300. You reraise to 1,000. The button thinks for a while and moves all-in, for 10,000.

Because the stacks are quite deep and there is plenty of money left to bet, it’s quite unlikely that the button has a medium-strength hand such as suited connectors. A typical player would either fold such a hand, or simply call and see a flop, hoping to hit something big or outplay you. By removing most of the middle-strength hands from the button’s range, we’ve left him with weak hands and strong hands – both of which make sense given the action. But for practical purposes his range isn’t completely polarised, for two reasons – first, the law of loose wiring dictates that sometimes, the button will make this move with a middle-strength hand; and second, some of the hands that are considered ‘strong’ in your opponent’s range are an underdog against your pocket jacks (for example, A-Q and A-K).

Bet Sizing in Polarised Situations

What about times when your range is polarised? How much should you bet to get maximum value when you have the nuts, and how much should you bet to minimise your chances of getting called when bluffing?

Normally, your bet sizing is based on balancing several factors. You want to maximise the chances that you will be called by a worse hand, maximise the value you will earn if you get called by a worst hand, but also minimise your loss if you are up against a stronger hand.

In a polarised situation, there is much less uncertainty about where you stand. If you have the nuts, you don’t need to think about minimising your losses when you’re facing a stronger hand – you simply want to extract maximum value. In such situations, I recommend making a larger than average bet, because the likelihood of being called does not decrease in proportion to the amount that you bet.

If you have nothing at all, you’re worrying only about getting better hands to fold, and couldn’t care less about extracting value from weaker hands (because there aren’t any!). You don’t want to make a small bet, because a small bet is more likely to be called than a big one. On the other hand, you don’t want to make an enormous bet relative to the pot, because you’ll be risking a lot to win a little.

In both situations, a larger-than-average bet makes sense, so that’s what I recommend when your hand range is clearly polarised. If your usual bet would be two-thirds of the pot, try overbetting the pot slightly in a polarised situation. Not only will this put your opponent to a tough decision, but it will maximise the chances of achieving your objective, no matter which end of the range your hand actually lies!

Hand Example 1: A Bluff

This infamous hand comes from the 2005 Monte Carlo Millions (one of the greatest televised poker tournaments ever broadcast). Phil Ivey is heads-up against Paul ‘ActionJack’ Jackson. The blinds are 12,000/24,000 with a 4,000 ante, and Ivey has 4,000,000 in chips relative to Jackson’s 1,000,000. Jackson limps on the button with 6s 5d, and Ivey raises to 74,000. Jackson calls.

The flop is Jc Jh 7c. Ivey bets 80,000. Jackson thinks for a while, and raises to 170,000. Ivey comes back over the top for 320,000, and Jackson re-re-raises to 470,000! Surely the hand is over at this point?

Phil Ivey doesn’t think so, and moves all-in! Jackson folds and is reduced to just 380,000 in chips.

So what is going on here? Well, in the heads-up game, the J-J-7 flop is extremely polarising. Both players are thinking the same way - either the opponent has a jack or pocket sevens, or he doesn’t – and if he doesn’t have one of those hands, he should fold to a raise. Both use this, combined with their people-reading skills, as an excuse to bluff.

If Jackson makes a mistake in this hand, it could be making such small raises in an effort to protect his stack. This allows Ivey to take the final action by moving all-in, putting him to the decision. Had Jackson made a larger raise, the decision would have been on Ivey and it’s possible he would have simply folded, preserved his chip lead, and looked for a better spot.

Hand Example 2: A Value Bet

This hand comes from the 2005 World Series of Poker – in fact, it’s the first hand played, in the very first level. Blinds are 25/50. Sam Farha raises to 200 with Ah 10d, and Oliver Hudson reraises to 450 with 10s 10c. Farha calls.

The flop is Ac Ad 10h, giving both players a full house! Both players check the flop, and the turn is the Qc. Hudson bets 300 into the 975 pot. Farha raises to 1300. Hudson moves all-in for 10,000, and Farha calls, eliminating Hudson from the tournament less than two minutes after the first hand was dealt!

What’s interesting is how both players play this polarised board with their strong hands. Hudson, who is by far the less experienced player, makes a small initial bet. But Farha, who holds the nuts, wants to earn the maximum value from his hand and makes a large raise – more than four times Hudson’s bet. This allows Hudson to make the terrible, if understandable mistake of moving all-in, doubling Farha up and putting him in a commanding position.

Note that in both our hand examples, the more experienced player and the eventual victor made the larger bets and raises – worth remembering if you find yourself in a polarised situation in future.