Black Friday
First published in InsidePoker Business magazine, May–June 2011.
I’m writing this just 48 hours after a defining moment in the history of online poker. Two days ago, the United States Department of Justice indicted eleven people, including the owners of my current and former employers, due to their involvement in offering a game of skill to willing adult participants in the US. As a result, the two largest and best-run online poker companies in the world pulled out of the US market. It’s too early to tell what the eventual result of this action will be, but suffice to say that I am extremely disappointed by these events, and my friends and colleagues who are caught up in it have my sympathy and full support.
In the past few days we’ve seen the best and worst from industry commentators. There is much talk of protecting freedoms, and how US players can take a stand and make their feelings known. But on the other hand, some of those who work for poker companies that pulled out of the US in 2006 are actually glad to see this happen, as they considered the playing field to be uneven after the UIGEA. I’m sure these people are looking forward to a highly competitive future marketplace. But consider what the DOJ’s intentions were when they filed their indiction.
First of all, the DOJ did not ever send a ‘cease and desist’ notice to the companies involved – they were happy with the murky legal situation as it was. They waited until the last possible moment, when online poker companies were at their richest but before legislation was enacted to clarify the legal situation, to make their move and make the greatest financial gain.
Secondly, they didn’t just go after the people involved in the alleged crimes – they went after entire companies, fully licensed businesses operating legally with the full approval of the government in other countries such as France, Italy, Belgium, Estonia and the United Kingdom. They want after bank accounts where the majority of funds on deposit belonged to European players and fully legal European limited companies. They even went after European contractors providing services to European online poker businesses.
I think it’s fair to assume that the DOJ wanted their indiction to have the maximum possible effect. That is, the DOJ wanted their actions to put thousands of hard-working US professional poker players, who pay millions of dollars in taxes each year, out of work. But it wasn’t enough to destroy careers on home soil - they wanted their indiction to destroy legal companies in Europe, and put the thousands of employees of those companies, who contribute millions of Euro to the European economy, out of work too. Still not content, the DOJ wanted to seize funds destined for charitable causes, such as the Japanese Red Cross (both PokerStars and Full Tilt Poker ran charity campaigns for Japan in which they promised to match any donations made).
This sort of action sets a horrible precedent, and if it is allowed to succeed it could produce an environment where online gaming is marginalised and untrusted. If players from Europe feel as though governments from other countries can step in at any time and confiscate money that belongs to them, then why would they ever deposit a single cent with your company?
What country is next? If European governments allow the DOJ’s action to succeed, what is to stop another country, such as Canada, enacting grey-area legislation, then swooping in to collect the profits at a later date? What is to stop another country seizing your company’s domain name based on shaky legal grounds?
Still glad to have a ‘level playing field’? Well, consider the fact that both PokerStars and Full Tilt have been forging a path for all other operators to follow, and how much they have contributed to the industry as a whole. When these companies break open a new market, the entire industry benefits. Also consider that PokerStars and Full Tilt Poker are still the industry leaders, and by a long way. Sure, in the short term both companies will lose players due to the loss of their domains (and the SEO value associated with them) and the panic caused by the US situation. But in the long term, these companies still have the best software, the best security, the best support and the most expertise – and if they survive these turbulent times, that is what will continue to make them successful.
Now this is business, so I understand why some companies, who have been operating with the excuse that the marketplace was somehow unfair and this was the cause of their gradual decline, would be glad to see this happen. But in time these people will see that the marketplace was fairer than they thought, and their excuses no longer wash.
The European poker industry must stop its bickering, its blame-apportioning and its excuse-making, and must unite to set a positive example. Together, we can forge a regulatory environment that is unparalleled, which leads the way for the rest of the world, and which shows the US government what a terrible mistake they have made by effectively banning the online game.
No more ridiculously high taxation that hurts both players and legitimate operators. No more kickbacks to corrupt ‘responsible gaming’ organisations. No more protectionism for weak local companies or government monopolies. No more licensing organisations that can’t spell poker.
Instead, we work together in creating the world’s best licensing regime for the game of poker, where players are protected from cheating, where companies are protected from fraud, and the cardrooms that offer the most innovative new features, treat their players the best, and offer the most fun environment in which to play, are the ones that succeed.
Such a market really is the utopia for everybody involved – players, ancillary businesses, and poker providers themselves. But to reach this utopia, we will need to work together and we will need to operate to the highest possible standards. This is a time of great peril but also great opportunity. Are you going to continue to make excuses, or will you join me on building a future together? Well?