Reputation in Online Poker

Written for InsidePoker Business magazine in October 2012.

Recently I’ve been reading the same thing over and over again. The poker industry is in a terrible state, the game is declining, and the fun is gone from poker. ‘What Happened to Poker?’ asked PokerNews’ Donnie Peters in October this year. ‘I couldn’t help but wonder where all the fun in poker has gone over the years… who wants to go and play with poker’s new generation?’. Earlier in the year, Mike Sexton encouraged poker pros to ‘wake up and smell the coffee’ and to behave responsibly and dress smartly, and Matt Glantz told us that ‘we should all be taking the time to promote the game we enjoy so much whenever and wherever the opportunity arises’, and encouraged players to ‘take off the headphones and make the extra effort to chat with the folks at your table for just a few minutes’.

The three aforementioned commentaries focused predominantly on live poker, but if live poker isn’t fun, then online poker is supposedly much worse. From reading the forums you’d think that there weren’t any recreational players left, and that the entire poker community consisted of 19 year old boys, multi-tabling and berating each other at every opportunity.

I’m an optimistic sort, and I tend to believe that things aren’t really as bad as some would have us believe. However, there is still no doubt in my mind that the game of online poker is less fun for new players than it used to be ten years ago when I played my own first hands of the online game.

I believe that new recreational players want two things – the chance to win, and the chance to enjoy themselves. Both of these have become more difficult since the poker boom – it’s more difficult to win because the learning curve in poker has changed so drastically, and it’s more difficult to have fun for several reasons. First, very few players are chatting socially at the tables, either because they are too busy multi-tabling or because they’re actually prohibited from chatting in a language they understand by the ridiculous ‘English only’ rule. Secondly, it’s an unfortunate truth that many players intentionally make online poker less fun for their opponents by berating their bad plays, quoting their losses from one of the datamining sites, or simply by slowing down the game because they can’t handle all of the tables they’re playing.

In my opinion, the real issue is that there is very little accountability for poker players, especially on the internet. In a brick-and-mortar poker room, you have a reputation that you carry with you at all times, because other people are able to recognise you. People who have played with you in the past know a little about you, and they know if you’re the kind of person that will make the game fun. If you act like an idiot and berate your opponents, then there are consequences – in particular, people are less likely to play with you in future. However, online you are just an anonymous screen name which is difficult to remember, and there are so many opponents that even if you berate everybody you meet, you will still get plenty of action.

This problem exists elsewhere on the internet too. Perhaps the most relevant example is online gaming on Xbox Live, Steam, and the PlayStation Network. On these platforms, most players play in a way that is fair and sporting, but there are always a limited few who intentionally spoil the game for others, by cheating or by abusing their opponents using the chat feature. So how do these gaming networks stop these idiots from spoiling the games for others?

The answer is that they have reputation systems. On Xbox Live for example, every player has a Gamerscore which is a rough measure of their gaming experience, along with a rating from zero to five stars that shows how much their opponents enjoyed playing against them. Any player who is logged in can leave feedback on another player which boosts or lowers this rating. This means that a person who cheats and abuses their opponents ends up with a lower than average rating. Other players can then make an informed decision about whether they want to play against this person.

Other internet sites have developed reputation systems too. For example, eBay has a well-established reputation system for buyers and sellers. If a seller rips off their customers, they end up with a poor reputation and lose custom in the future. If a buyer has a poor reputation, perhaps because they didn’t pay up for a product they ordered, then a potential seller can require the buyer to pay up front or safeguard themselves in other ways.

In fact, reputation systems are all over the internet. Internet users can rate buyers, sellers, forum posters, email senders, entire websites, and individual products. But not poker players!

In my opinion, online poker could benefit greatly from a robust reputation system. However, because of the competitive nature of the game, players rating other players in isolation would not be the best approach (it would probably turn the feature into a fish finder). It would be better to combine a small element of player-on-player rating with an impartial automated system, that boosted a player’s rating when they did things that we consider good (like playing quickly, contributing to the online community, chatting at the tables and making people feel welcome), and reduced the player’s rating when they did things that we consider undesirable (such as bumhunting, short-stacking, hitting and running, playing slowly, or abusing their opponents in the chat).

In order to be robust, the system would need to have safeguards against abuse, but there is a great deal of precedent for how to deal with this with the already-existing reputation systems on the internet.

Imagine if you could see the average rating for every table as soon as you open the lobby. You’d instantly know which tables had the most fun opponents, so you’d play at those tables when you could. Such a system would be a major incentive for players to do things that made the games more fun – because if you had a poor reputation, you wouldn’t get much action. When combined with a Zynga or Xbox-style achievements model that also rewarded positive behaviours, a reputation system could have a revolutionary effect on game quality.

Since a great deal of the players who are graduating to the live game these days have cut their teeth online, improving the behaviour of players online will eventually have a positive effect on the fun and enjoyment in live poker too. That will translate into more entertainment and excitement in poker TV shows, which in turn will result in a rejuvenated interest in the game among recreational players, and more of those players signing up to play online. By encouraging your customers to exhibit positive behaviours using a reputation system, you can help to safeguard the future of the game. Then finally we can stop whining about what is wrong with poker, and simply enjoy the ride and reap the rewards.