Set Mining
First published in PokerPlayer magazine, issue 64, September 2010.
If you read hand discussions in magazines like this one, or on strategy forums online, you’ll often hear the term ‘set mining’ used. But what does it mean?
In simple terms, set mining is getting involved with small pairs, in an attempt to flop a set and win big. The concept of set mining assumes that if you don’t flop a set, you’ll usually give up after the flop. It’s something of a derogatory term, in that it’s often used to describe a strategy used by unimaginative, very tight players, especially on the internet. But set mining is actually a perfectly reasonable strategy in the right situations.
Set Mining is closely linked to the concept of implied odds. Implied odds are an extension of pot odds, which take into account the money you could win and lose on future betting rounds, in addition to the current round. You can use implied odds to justify a call where the pot odds would usually be insufficient (or conversely but more rarely, a fold where the pot odds seem good).
To give an extreme example, let’s say you’re playing 9-Max $1/$2 NL Hold’em and you hold pocket deuces on the button. The UTG player, who is very tight, moves all in for $200, and everyone folds to you. Should you call?
There is $203 in the pot and it costs you $200 to call, so your pot odds are 1.015 to 1. Obviously you should fold your deuces, as these odds just aren’t good enough against a tight opening range.
Now let’s say that instead of moving in, the UTG player raises to $6. The effective stacks are still $200. The pot odds still won’t be good enough to call, but remember that your opponent has $194 left to bet. If everything goes well, you could win their entire stack.
This is a clear set-mining scenario, as you’re looking to flop a set and very rarely will you continue after the flop without one. Could it be worth it calling the $6 raise with the intention of folding every time you miss? The answer is complex and depends on many things.
Before going on, I should make it clear that we’re talking about Hold’em only in this article. Omaha is very different and calling raises with small pairs to try and make sets is not often a smart play.
You will flop a set or quads about once in every 8.5 times you see the flop with a pocket pair. So even if you assume that you will be paid off every time you flop a set or quads, you still need to compensate for the times that you miss. Sticking with the same simple example, 7.5 times you will miss your set and fold to a bet on the flop, losing $6 each time, for a total cost of $45. Therefore, the 1 time that you do hit your set, you need to win at least $45 just to break even – so you’re looking to make this type of call against opponents with deep stacks. As a rough guide, many players use the ’10 times rule’ for this situation, and will only make the call when their opponent has at least ten times the initial raise in reserve. This larger figure accounts for the times when you hit a set, but don’t get paid off. In tournaments or short-stacked ring games, it’s often much harder to justify this type of call because there simply isn’t enough money to win (your opponents won’t often have 10 times the initial raise).
The next factor to consider is how often your opponent will commit a lot of money after the flop with the worst hand. Thankfully, it’s common in low limit games for players to commit their entire stack with hands like top pair, or an overpair – and this is the ideal environment in which to set mine. In tougher games, players have learned to read their opponents better and fold big hands when necessary, so you should be less inclined to set mine.
It also helps if your opponent is likely to have the sort of hand which will call you after the flop. Although you might expect that loose players would be better to set mine against, this isn’t necessarily true as loose players will often not have anything to call you with after the flop and therefore might not pay you off. It’s much better for your opponent to be either a calling station or a very aggressive player, as then you can make money either by value betting your hand (in the case of the calling station) or by slowplaying (in the case of the aggressive player).
In addition to your opponent’s aggressiveness, it’s actually better to be set mining against an early position raise, which is more likely to represent strength than a raise from late position, which could be a steal. It also helps to be in position after the flop, as this will allow you to better judge from your opponent’s actions whether you should play aggressively straight away, or slow down and allow them to catch up a little.
What should you do if the pot is reraised after you call? Well, you simply apply the same criteria again. It’s now even more likely that your opponent has a hand to pay you off, but the amount you have to commit to the pot is larger. However, if the effective stacks are really deep, you might still be able to win a lot of money and it might be worth calling.
Now that you know the secret to set mining, you should be careful not to take it too far! Many players set mine too often, especially late in tournaments where the stacks are rarely deep enough to justify it. One common scenario in which it is not usually profitable to set mine is when you’re playing against a strong, aggressive opponent who will exercise good pot control after the flop. Against this type of player, you might not make enough money with your set to justify calling the raise.
Another situation where you might not set mine is if it’s highly likely that there will be a reraise after you call, and you won’t be able to call that reraise. If there’s a player at your table who is fond of the squeeze-play, or if there’s a player behind you that is looking for a good opportunity to move all-in, then you should be much less liberal in calling the first raise.
Should you worry about your opponent making a higher set than you (so called ‘set over set’)? In short, no. It’s very unlikely that your opponent will actually make a set at the same time as you - if somehow you know for certain that your opponent has a pocket pair, there is still only a 1 in 99 chance of you both flopping sets at the same time, and of course there is a good chance that your opponent has a different type of hand. So unless you have some sort of incredible read on your opponent, you should almost never be willing to fold a set on the flop. It’s just too likely that you’re winning.
You should be more cautious when the pot is multi-way of course. If there are 5 or 6 players in the pot, the chances of set-over-set are higher, and of course there’s also a chance that your set will run into a flush or a straight. But in general, multiway pots can be beneficial, as they increase both your initial pot odds and the chances that somebody will make a hand with which to pay you off. If you’re too scared of set over set to commit your chips, then perhaps poker is not the game for you!
Some Examples
When Set Mining Works: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=07U3b70yEsY
This is a hand taken from High Stakes Poker Season 5. In the hand, both Peter Eastgate and David Benyamine try to set mine against Daniel Negreanu’s early position raise.
Benyamine flops a set and plays it aggressively, building a $100,000 pot before the turn, when he makes quads! A clever small bet, representing a draw, gets Daniel to commit his entire stack drawing dead. Benyamine wins a pot worth $416,200.
When Set Mining Fails: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Qp5YOubXIM
Another High Stakes Poker hand. In this multiway pot, Tom Dwan has made a ‘punish the limpers’ raise, and Phil Laak calls to set mine with pocket fives. Unfortunately, David Peat has kings and reraises, forcing Laak to commit a much larger portion of his stack than he intended. Laak misses the flop and is forced to lay down his hand, losing $20,800 in the pot.
This is classic example of how set mining can go wrong – Laak gets trapped between two aggressive players with strong hands and is forced to pay too high a price to see the flop. Of course, Laak could have tripled up had he hit a five, so the situation isn’t completely clear cut… but when is poker ever clear cut?