Table Selection

First published in PokerPlayer magazine, issue 65, October 2010.

Introduction

Take a second and answer this simple question. What is the most important skill that a winning poker player has?

Some say that the ability to read your opponents well is the most important skill. Some would say that strong analytical or mathematical skills are the key factor. Others would argue that discipline and solid fundamentals are what matter. However, all of these answers are utterly wrong.

The number one most important skill that a winning player has, without a shred of doubt, is the ability to choose games in which they have an edge. No other skill has as profound an effect on a player’s long-term results. A commonly-repeated anecdote has you imagining that you’re the ninth-best player in the world. You’re good enough to beat almost anybody, but if you sit in a game with the top eight players in the world, you’re going to lose! Since most of us cannot reasonably expect to be in the top nine, it follows that good game selection is going to be very important to our results.

This article will focus on game selection in ring games and single-table Sit & Gos. Game selection for multi-table tournaments is more complex (partly because you can’t choose your seat or table) and won’t be covered here.

Game Selection in Live Games

Game Selection simply means attempting to choose a game in which you have an edge. Finding a good game that suits your style means it’s more likely that you’ll make a profit (and enjoy the session). Imagine if you will, the following two tables at your local poker room:

Table A is a £2/£5 No Limit Hold’em game with 8 tough opponents. Most of the players at the table are young. Some players are wearing headphones, and most look to be concentrating. Nobody is drinking alcohol.

Table B is a £0.25/£0.50 Mixed Game with 5 opponents of varying age. It’s a lively game with lots of chatting and smiling, and there are several beers dotted around the table.

Which table would you choose and why?

Some players would be put off by the small stakes of Table B, or perhaps they don’t know how to play any game except No Limit Hold’em, so they would choose Table A. I would choose Table B every time, for the following reasons:

  • In the mixed game format, I’m more likely to come across weak play, as it’s rare for a player to be good at every single game.
  • Young players are usually tougher opponents than older players, who may not have as much time to dedicate to the game, or who may think they have nothing left to learn. A table with players of different ages is likely to be easier than a table full of young players.
  • Players chatting and smiling are not only more fun to play with (which is important to me) but they are also less likely to be concentrating. Also, players who are enjoying themselves are more likely to stay at the table when they go broke, which means the game is less likely to break up.
  • Lastly, alcohol is the great loosener! A player who is drinking alcohol probably isn’t taking the game too seriously, and is probably playing for recreation. Alcohol impairs the decision-making process, causing more mistakes and resulting in more profit for me.

It wouldn’t be unusual for Table B to be a more profitable game, despite the stakes being significantly smaller. When I play live, I try to scout the tables briefly, looking for big stacks, big pots, tough players to avoid, smiling faces, and players who aren’t taking the game seriously. You may have different motivations for playing poker, and so might look for different things. Perhaps you want to challenge yourself against tough opponents, so you would choose Table A. In that case, good luck to you!

Table Selection Online

Online, you can’t look at players and tell whether they’re smiling, drinking, or having a good time. Conversely, you have some information available to you that you don’t have in a live poker room. Poker sites publish different information to their lobbies and calculate the information in different ways, but the following three stats are almost ubiquitous:

Players to Flop: The general idea is that the higher the value, the more players saw the flop in hands recently played at that table. A high value suggests that opponents are entering the pot with sub-par hands or that the table is somewhat passive. If you’re looking for a game with lots of loose opponents, then a game with a high ‘Players to Flop’ value might be good. Some sites are now starting to offer the ‘Voluntarily Put Money In Pot’ (VP$IP) statistic instead of Players to Flop, and it’s a more useful indication of the looseness of the table.

Average Pot: If the average pot size is large but the Players to Flop is low, it suggests that the table is aggressive, with lots of betting and raising. Alternatively, if the average pot is large but Players to Flop is high, this suggests that there are players who continue too long with weak hands, calling or raising bets that they shouldn’t. In any case, a high value means that the table is full of action, which is usually a good thing.

Hands Per Hour: If you’re a winning player and are earning a certain number of big blinds per 100 hands, then it is in your interest to play as many hands as you can per hour in order to maximise your hourly rate. You can do this by choosing tables with a high ‘hands per hour’ value, which tend to have less multi-tablers and more players making quick decisions.

It’s usually also possible to get an idea of the Average Stack Size at the table. The deeper the stacks, the more complex the game and the more opportunity you have to make a profit if you have an edge.

Another option available to you online is to take notes on your opponents. You can colour-code these notes, for example by assigning one colour to strong players and another to weak players. You can then quickly scan the tables looking for one with a lot of weak players. It’s usually difficult to find a game with only weak players in it, but if you can identify which opponents are weak, which are strong, and which are predictable and unlikely to get in your way, then you’re already a step ahead of the game.

Game Selection in Online Sit & Gos

If you’re a Sit & Go player, you won’t have statistics like ‘Players Per Flop’ available to you, so you must take excellent notes on opponents you’ve encountered in the past, and use them effectively.

Pay close attention to the games that you are registering for - which means NOT using the ‘register to any tournament’ feature available on some sites, and not blindly registering for as many games as you can handle. If you register first, then you should monitor which opponents join after you, and be prepared to unregister if there are too many tough players. Better still, you can monitor the tournament lobbies looking for games with weak opponents, and join only the least-tough games – this strategy is particularly effective in Heads-Up SNGs, where you can look out for a clueless opponent and then face them one-on-one.

Don’t be too stubborn to simply avoid a game if it looks like it’s full of good players. Find a better spot to invest your entry fee – even if it means ending your session early and coming back later.

The Debate

Game selection online is a divisive issue. Players are obviously entitled to choose good games, but on the other hand it’s not in the best long-term interests of the game if losing players are immediately stripped of all of their money by professionals. The fish analogy is a good one – trawl too much in the same place, and you quickly run out of fish to catch. But how far can players reasonably go before legitimate table selection becomes unethical behaviour?

My feeling is that players are entitled to use any information they have acquired themselves through their own play to help them choose which tables to join. Programs like PokerTracker and Hold’em Manager offer additional subscription-based table selection tools that use your own hand histories to help you choose the best tables, and these could certainly be useful to a winning player. On the other hand, I feel that it’s wrong to use information from hands that you didn’t play. Gathering information on hands in which you did not participate is known as datamining.

It’s a fine line, but the more reputable online poker sites are starting to clamp down on both datamining itself, and datamining tools like SharkScope and PokerTableRatings, which breach both the sites’ Terms of Service and the confidence of players. You can be punished by some sites for using these tools while playing online, so I won’t recommend using them without checking with your chosen poker room first.